Will the US Abandon Ukraine?
2024 election will test American character, faithfulness and commitment to ideals
The Republican Party seems highly likely to nominate a presidential candidate in 2024 who thinks the US should scale back its support for Ukraine, or even abandon the fledgling nation. The overwhelming favorite to be nominated, Donald Trump has expressed skepticism if not downright opposition to Ukraine aid.
The election will fit historical patterns when questions were asked about the American character. Former British Prime Minister Winston Churchill, interviewed by journalist Stewart Alsop at the close of World War II, doubted whether the US had the attention span or fortitude to support long wars or decades-long nation-building projects like the British and other historic empires that hugely influenced the world. Luckily, US involvement in WWII lasted only from December 7, 1941 until September 2, 1945, when the war in the Pacific officially ended. The European Recovery Program, known as the Marshall Plan, was also relatively short. It lasted from April 1948 to December 1951.
“America, it is a great and strong country, like a workhorse pulling the rest of the world out of despond and despair,” Churchill observed. “But will it stay the course?"
Churchill, who died in 1965, might have been surprised that the US truly stayed the course of the Cold War to see the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1989. He probably would not have been surprised that the US abandoned Vietnam in April 1975, just 11 years after President Lyndon Johnson escalated American involvement under false pretenses in August 1964.
I hated the “stay the course” mantra when it was used by Alsop in his 1971 Newsweek columns to justify continued American involvement in Vietnam. I felt the US had sacrificed enough — 58,000 men — in Vietnam. Acknowledging that huge sacrifice instead of denying the reality of quagmire in Southeast Asia, was a sign of character, I believed then.
But I like the “stay the course” mantra in reference to Ukraine, where Americans aren’t sacrificing soldiers but simply lending financial support in what is widely perceived as a battle between democracy and self-determination against autocracy and authoritarianism.
My friend Bruce Johnson notes that Archbishop Jean Jadot, a Belgian who served as Pope Paul VI's envoy to the United States, said much the same thing in 1980 about the American character
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Slender Threads / Global Citizens / Public History to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.